Real Pain: Transgenerational Trauma Through Historical Echoes

As our plane ascended over Malta's rugged coastline, I reflected on the island's tumultuous history—​from the Great Siege of 1565 to the relentless bombings of World War II. The resilience of the Maltese people in the face of repeated invasions is a testament to the enduring human spirit. This contemplation set the stage for my in-flight viewing of "A Real Pain," a film that delves into the complexities of transgenerational trauma among Holocaust survivors' descendants. The movie's exploration of inherited suffering resonated deeply, drawing parallels between Malta's historical scars and the protagonists' personal battles.​

"A Real Pain," directed by Jesse Eisenberg, shows the lives of two Jewish American cousins, David and Benji, as they journey through Poland to connect with their grandmother's Holocaust legacy. The film poignantly explores transgenerational trauma, illustrating how the horrors experienced by one generation can echo through the lives of their descendants.  

Understanding Transgenerational Trauma

Transgenerational trauma refers to the transmission of traumatic experiences from survivors to their descendants, affecting their psychological and emotional well-being. Research has shown that children of Holocaust survivors often exhibit heightened anxiety, depression, and stress responses, even without direct exposure to the original traumatic events. ​

The mechanisms underlying this phenomenon are complex and multifaceted:​

• Epigenetic Changes: Traumatic experiences can lead to epigenetic modifications—changes in gene expression without altering the DNA sequence—that are inheritable. For instance, studies have found that children of Holocaust survivors exhibit epigenetic changes in genes related to stress response, such as the glucocorticoid receptor gene (NR3C1). ​
  

• Psychological Transmission: Parental behaviors influenced by trauma, such as overprotectiveness or emotional unavailability, can affect children's development, leading to increased vulnerability to mental health issues. ​
  

• Social and Cultural Factors: The collective memory of a community, including narratives of past atrocities, can shape the identities and stress responses of subsequent generations.

Visit HealoVerse to explore the AI-powered VR Psychotherapy in combination with at-home ketamine

Manifestations in 'A Real Pain'

In "A Real Pain," the main characters, David and Benji, embody the effects of transgenerational trauma:​

• David's Anxious Demeanor: Portrayed by Jesse Eisenberg, David exhibits heightened anxiety and a need for control. This aligns with research indicating that children of trauma survivors often experience increased anxiety and hyper-vigilance, potentially due to inherited epigenetic modifications affecting stress-response systems. 
  

• Benji's Emotional Turmoil: Kieran Culkin's character, Benji, displays emotional volatility and a pervasive sense of aimlessness. Such behaviors mirror findings that descendants of trauma survivors may struggle with identity formation and emotional regulation, possibly stemming from disrupted family dynamics and the internalization of unresolved grief. ​
  

• Strained Familial Relationships: The cousins' interactions are marked by underlying tension and misunderstandings, reflecting the complex family dynamics often seen in families affected by historical trauma. Studies have shown that unaddressed trauma can lead to communication barriers and emotional distance among family members. ​
  

• Search for Identity and Meaning: Their journey to Poland signifies a quest to understand their heritage and personal identities. This resonates with the experiences of many descendants of Holocaust survivors, who often grapple with the weight of their legacy while seeking individual purpose. ​ 

Their journey through Poland serves as a backdrop for confronting their shared history, highlighting how unprocessed trauma can strain familial relationships and personal identities.​ 

Evidence from Holocaust Studies

Extensive research supports the depiction of transgenerational trauma in the film:​

• Epigenetic Changes: Studies have found that children of Holocaust survivors exhibit epigenetic modifications in genes related to stress response, such as the glucocorticoid receptor gene (NR3C1). These changes may contribute to altered stress hormone regulation and increased vulnerability to anxiety and depression. ​
  

• Psychological Impact: Research indicates that descendants of Holocaust survivors may experience increased vulnerability to mental health issues, such as anxiety and depression, due to the unresolved trauma of their ancestors.
  
  

• Family Dynamics: Studies have shown that trauma experienced by Holocaust survivors can significantly influence family relationships, affecting communication patterns and emotional bonds among descendants. ​
  

These findings underscore the film's portrayal of David and Benji's complex relationship as they navigate their inherited pain.

Conclusion

"A Real Pain" offers a compelling exploration of transgenerational trauma, reflecting the enduring impact of historical atrocities on subsequent generations. By intertwining personal narratives with historical context, the film sheds light on the importance of acknowledging and addressing inherited trauma to foster healing and understanding.